AAP and the Emperor’s clothes Syndrome

The tremendous (and very well deserved) success of AAP in the Delhi elections this time, came as no surprise given the resentment and anger among the common citizens of India. In a country where 1000 crore scams make the news every second week, the Aam Aadmi Party and its genuine efforts towards transparency is definitely a breath of fresh air.

But what puzzles me is, how nobody in the country has taken the time to question the practicality of the solutions put forth by the Aam Aadmi Party. Agreed, Arvind Kejriwal and team have come up with highly ingenious and genuinely democratic ideas to tackle common political issues (proposals like, Delhi will be divided into different wards and the citizens of each ward will decide and regulate the matainence of each ward Or the people will decide the price of petrol and other daily commodities etc) but one can’t help but think if AAP is being too disillusioned.

For example, let us for a moment assume that AAP has it’s way and the common citizens are allowed to fix petrol (say) prices. But then why would a common citizen pay if he has to decide the price and not take it for free? Can we then hope the economy to thrive? Okay, maybe we can argue the common citizen is not a fool to demand petrol for free and what AAP means is common citizens will be a contributing if not a deciding factor in fixing prices. But then decisions of development and economy require expertise and debate and cannot be driven by mere public sentiment.

A nation of hypocrites that we are, most supporters of AAP, you’ll be surprised to find, are merely following AAP because being a part of “change” and “revolution” is the new cool. Just like the subjects of the emperor in the popular fable “The Emperor’s Clothes”** who merely ignore the obvious to seem part of the crowd. While some may scoff away the criticism and ridicule even the  thought of questioning AAP’s functionality, let us not forget mere ‘good intentions’ cannot be enough to govern a country.

In the end, the point being, even although AAP symbolizes transparency and honesty let us not get over-whelmed and also focus on whether they be trusted with development and progress.

“We thought we had the answers, but it was the questions we had which were wrong” – Bono

** The Emperor’s Clothes is a popular fable in which a emperor is conned by two men who sell him an invisible cloth and claim that it can only be seen by ‘intelligent’ people. Afraid of being called dumb everyone pretends to “see” it until a young boy points out the obvious.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “AAP and the Emperor’s clothes Syndrome

  1. Juilee, point agreed, infact AAP will be a good n strong opposition party, which thankfully, dey have decided to take the job. With so many strong minded n with strong views it will definately b a bit difficult for d party as a whole to take a decision.

    • Ekta, true! It’s a great party and it’s efforts at transparency need to be lauded, not to forget it is also the only party which rebukes it’s MLAs when needed and accepts blame for it’s mistake. If only it could show the people it is capable of reaching a unanimous decision and address other important issues of the country like National security, Maoism, Foreign policy… I think we have a winner.

      • Point taken , but every party will have some short comings , its just that, we all have to put some faith in them, give them chance and time and eventually they will address all the issues. It’s just the matter of time for us and experience for AAP.

      • Yes matter of experience for AAP. Well said!
        My point was only that people also need to look at where AAP falls short instead of hailing it as magic wand which will solve all problems overnight. Because only when you have identified your shortcomings can you seek to correct them. Faith and not blind-faith is what we need.
        That being said, I sincerely hope AAP evolves as a party (in the ample time that it has) and is here to stay 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s